Marty's Pizza Pasta & Subs
No photo available for this business
Business Information
Pizza, Restaurants, CaterersItalian
Customer Reviews (16 reviews)
Guest G.
on Judys Book Nov 01, 2010We have been a customer of Marty's for over 25 yrs. This weekend we visited at 6:30pm when they said they got a rush of people. Our pizza came the wrong size and burnt. We told the waitress and she had a manager tell us he'd... (more)
mopa
on Citysearch Jul 26, 2009There is a pizza joint place in New York which now will deliver a pie to your door fresh by next day air... Now I wish Marty's did the same. I had tried many, many pizza's with sausage, they are always very greasy, too... (more)
Snark123456
on Citysearch May 19, 2008Marty's makes the best pizza in town, and Mike is the number one delivery driver in town. Hey Mike from Snark the Illinois F.I.B. (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 01, 2007We have always had great pizza at Martys. They do have an extensive menu, but we always seem to want pizza here. The restaurant is clean and seating is good. There is a small gameroom for the kids too. I don't think you can... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Sep 25, 2007We've been going to Marty's for years now, and nothing ever seems to change. The food is still very good (especially the pizza), and the service is still excellent. Seating never seems to be a problem. Besides dining... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Apr 12, 2007Marty's has been a staple in the area for years. A great place to stop in with friends and family for a sitdown meal. Location is good on bluemound, close to lots of shops. (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch Feb 26, 2007Restaurant delivers fresh homestyle pizzas and offers catering for all events as well as delivery. (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 05, 2006I use Marty's Pizza for catering at work a lot. They are located near my office, and they are a great about delivering to us when needed. have had really good success with them as a caterer, except for their breakfast... (more)
Glenn R.
on Judys Book May 31, 2006I have been coming here for years.Have been here for parties, family get togethers, and other events.The best thing I can say about Marty's is that I have never been disappointed in the quality of food that they serve.... (more)
.Krista ..
on Judys Book Apr 01, 2006When I first moved out this way I kept hearing about Marty's. Seemed everyone I spoke to asking where there was a good pizza joint at referred me to Marty's.We finally took the plunge for the first time there with... (more)
jlf27
on Citysearch Nov 07, 2005I love Marty's Pizza, and have been going there my entire life. The pizza and the food is always excellent. The staff is very nice and always very accomodating. Matry's has its own recipes and uses fresh ingredients.... (more)
kgirl28
on Citysearch Oct 09, 2005I am a regular at Martys. I think the whole resturant is great. The pizza is very yummy. All the food is tasty. I highly recommend this resturant. (more)
caiti1
on Citysearch Aug 01, 2005Been coming to Marty's for a while. The last time there, we had to seat ourselves. They gave us styrofoam plates, and had us come to the counter to order! What's the deal with that? The pizza is still AWESOME regardless.... (more)
Kendra C.
on Judys Book Jul 26, 2005Marty's is a small restaurant but sure makes up for that in food! I had a chance to try their calzones and oh my goodness. First, they are huge. They are more than half of a dinner plate. The crust is crispy on the outside... (more)
gyorke
on Citysearch Jan 20, 2005It's very easy to tell the other reviewer has no idea what pizza is. I now live in Atlanta, Ga and cannot find anyone who offers such great italian sausage on their pizza. I visit Martys each time I visit Wisconsin. Marty... (more)
ElizabethJK
on Citysearch Nov 03, 2002This pizza place has great thin crust pizza (and I'm a thick crust fan). They offer lots of varieties. On a cold winter night, the building is warm and inviting and the aroma of pizza is heavenly when you come in from the... (more)