5 O'clock Club
No photo available for this business
Business Information
RestaurantsMasterCard
Top Sentiments among 5 O'clock Club Reviewers
Best steaks
Incredible filets
Generous salads
Big drinks
Great sourdough bread
Huge sour cream
Great mushrooms
Decent wine list
Generous potatoes
Best cooked meat
Customer Reviews (61 reviews)
Tiffany G.
on Judys Book Nov 19, 2009Best steak(porterhouse) anywhere, always go on my birthday (more)
Mad Dog
on Citysearch Aug 29, 2009When you walk in, it feels and looks like Frank Sinatra or Dean Martin would of loved this place. The bartenders greet you...you sit at the bar, order your food and then you are seated at your table. The staff is... (more)
PBellakma
on Citysearch Jan 21, 2009After reading the posting dated 1/18/2009, I felt as if I needed to write a review in order to defend a good friend. Coerpers, now just 5 O'Clock Club, is an old friend. She is right, the atmosphere feels like the 1950's;... (more)
ClassicShe
on Citysearch Jan 17, 2009After hearing a friend talk about how great this place we for years, we thought we would give it a try. I was expecting something similar to the Jackson Grill, so I as terribly disappointed with this dining experience.... (more)
bluebath
on Citysearch Sep 05, 2008The Steak is wonderful each and every time I have been there. I have been going there for years. The wait staff has always been great. It's nice to see somethings have not changed during the change of ownership. There... (more)
carlito14
on Citysearch Aug 24, 2008This is a real mans steakhouse - a place where blue collar, white collar don't matter. You are there to socialize and enjoy the best steaks ever. Whoever wrote the last review MUST have been a disgrunteld employee. Who... (more)
CriticalCritic1
on Citysearch Apr 19, 2008After reading, and enjoying, the variation in reviews I think I can sort things out. First, the restaurant is no longer caled "Coerper's 5 O'Clock Club, it is the "Five O'Clock Club House of Steaks". The reason is that... (more)
mfperone
on Citysearch Dec 07, 2007We just ate at Coerper's for the first time during the week of 12/2/07. After hearing for years about how great this place was..I perhaps expected too much. My steak was okay but by no means was it extraordinary,... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Sep 15, 2007When Coerper's 5 O'Clock Club changed ownership a couple years back, I was worried that Milwaukee lost one of the best steak joints it had. To my relief (and many others) the new ownership did a superb job at preserving... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Sep 07, 2007I heard it was good. Unfortunately, I did not experience that. The general area it's located does not make one feel safe. The ambiance is supper club 1970. I personally like a place that looks like it was updated within... (more)
bathbabe81
on Citysearch Aug 22, 2007Having travelled far and wide this place is definately worth the visit. Very different from the typical dining experience. I mean that in a good way. I feel people tend to confuse a good dining experience when they go... (more)
jamelea7
on Citysearch Aug 20, 2007Very busy place. The atmosphere is different for a place that serves classy food. The drinks were great, service was excellent and the presentation of food was amazing. Ordered the Porterhouse and Lobster. It was... (more)
ntrgg
on Citysearch Jul 21, 2007I dont smoke, and I did not have a problem with anyone smoking at the club. Hands Down the best steak ever !! I live in MG Brasil, and we have some of the best steak in the world here. I have also eaten at some of the finest... (more)
amatra
on Citysearch Jul 15, 2007The food was very good but the atmosphere has little to be desired. Very very smokey! There was so much smoke the night we where there I felt like I was eating a cigarette by the end of my meal. I had to take a shower before I... (more)
staviola
on Citysearch Jan 19, 2007Fantastic HUGE steaks, wonderful '50s decor... old school! If it's not broken, don't fix it! I called them at 8:00pm and they said they had a table, I was seated by 8:30... I'll be back.... (more)
wmst
on Citysearch Oct 25, 2006Get over the location, get over the interior design. This is THE PLACE for steak. Order at the bar, and after you are seated you will be amazed at the plate of steak that appears in from ot you! If you can't finish it - bring... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Jul 10, 2006Well, after hearing the hoopla about this restaurant I decided to take my boyfriend there for a nice birthday dinner. Honestly, I was a bit disappointed. The meat was pretty tender but not very flavorful....it... (more)
gamotomagazaki
on Citysearch Jul 09, 2006My father used to take me to this place. (By the way it's called Five o' Clock steakhouse) Same phenomenal steak, same 50's vibe. Very cool, like walking into a movie set or something. Now me and my wife celebrate... (more)
alvaradofam419
on Citysearch Mar 23, 2006The restaurant has been sold ,but continues the same great tradition Ted Coerper and his family started over 50 years ago. Same menu same chef same bartenders (minus Ted)waitresses, etc.They will close for the... (more)
10schic
on Citysearch Feb 04, 2006Coerper's is classic. After moving away from Milwaukee, my fiance and I find ourselves struggling to find a steak house that even comes close to Coerper's. Absolutely no comparison. The food, the service, the... (more)
leahluvsjerry
on Citysearch Feb 02, 2006Going for my fourth time and looking forward to it! I love it so much that three of the four visits was MY TREAT. (more)
suenbob
on Citysearch Jan 02, 2006The steak is fantastic. I have been numerous times and it is always perfect! The salad is always fresh and I love the dressings. The only complaints I have are the reservation policy, the smoking and the... (more)
klininger_53
on Citysearch Dec 18, 2005I travel regularly and have to say it was the best. Price way steep for the location, but worth every penny. Try the filet! (more)
steelmansteaks
on Citysearch Sep 25, 2005The whole idea is the Big juicy steak of the past with the original supper club experience . They do it with excellence . Ribeyes done to perfection , Brown Mumblers served at the bar , by Budha or the Kid . The bartenders... (more)
tmalia23
on Citysearch Jun 05, 2005You will never find a better steak! The mushrooms on the side are great, the salad and bread are great and the wine is great too! (more)
johnniesharley
on Citysearch Mar 08, 2005If you would have told me that I would have spent 50 buck on a dinner with drinks before I went to Coerpers I would have said no way but now I will do it any time I can. There is no better steak in the country and I have eaten as... (more)
bobnlaurie
on Citysearch Oct 25, 2004Hands down the biggest, best flavored steaks my wife and I have ever been served anywhere in the USA. They char the outside, cook to a perfect temp inside, and cover with mouthwatering au ju and button mushrooms. It's... (more)
sarek
on Citysearch May 17, 2004Coerper's is not in the best neighborhood, but it's got this great 50's old-school charm. I love this place, atmosphere and their steaks are the best. Everytime we go, we grab the filets -- incredible! Salads are... (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch May 13, 2004<b>The Scene </b> <br>For the past 50 years, this has been the place for steak in Milwaukee. Little has changed in this 1950s-style supper club; why mess with success? Like a radio contest, the phone starts ringing... (more)
rickshaw
on Citysearch Apr 28, 2004Coerper's doesn't have much in the atmosphere department, but the steak is the best I've ever had. I've looked long and hard for a better place, but there is none in my book. If you want a great steak, this is the place. If... (more)
ghokey
on Citysearch Mar 11, 2004Coerper's may have one of the best steaks in the entire country. The room is cosy and the service is right on. (more)
hinners
on Citysearch Aug 01, 2003I remember my uncle taking me to a Milwaukee restaurant after Braves games in the 50s but couldn't remember where it was. Well, Coerper's was it and our party of eight enjoyed great steaks the day before going to... (more)
john_petik
on Citysearch Jul 23, 2003the whole experience will keep you coming back! great food & overall value...salad and relish tray keep you busy while waiting for the main course... which is WELL worth the wait! pay the man at the gated lot for... (more)
Ratda
on Citysearch May 14, 2003We recently dined on a friday evening (April 25th) and the food was excellent, as always. However, our waitress was less than attentive. In fact, we got so thirsty waiting for her to come around, that we actually had to... (more)
goddess8295
on Citysearch Apr 25, 2003Coerper's is the best!!!! They have been around a long time and continue to out do themselves. (more)
JohnnySmokovich
on Citysearch Feb 04, 2003The absolute best steaks I have ever. From tenderness to flavor, they are top notch. Aside from the signature steaks, the ribs and shrimp scampi are also delicious! (more)
mscarpen
on Citysearch Jan 29, 2003What can I say but WOW?!!! This place is off the chart when it comes to good steak. The beef starts at 28 ounces and goes up from there. Despite the HUGE portions, the place is very reasonably priced. But remember two very... (more)
cindykoboske
on Citysearch Jan 21, 2003My husband and I have been going to Coerper's for years. We have been to many steakhouses, even World Renown across the states but this is the BEST EVER! A must try before you die!!... (more)
ojala
on Citysearch Jan 13, 2003Biggest and best tasting steak I've ever had for the price. Plus, the salad bar, brought right to your table, is fantastic. Wonderful overall dining experience. (more)
queenb8789
on Citysearch Jan 12, 2003This is the best steak I have ever had. Melts in your mouth. Great sourdough bread, great salad. (more)