Wagstaff's Steak House
No photo available for this business
Business Information
Banquet RoomsMasterCard
Customer Reviews (17 reviews)
phistic09
on Citysearch Jan 10, 2009I have eaten at Wagstaff's several times and they have never failed to impress me. The dining room is romantic and semi-formal, offering a great atmosphere for a first date, engagement proposal, or simply a family... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Jun 11, 2008You decide how thick you'd like your beef sliced tableside prior to your server heading to the kitchen. Steaks, chicken, shellfish and fish cooked over REAL charcoal. Good food, but in this person's opinion, over... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Dec 16, 2007Good steaks, delicious desserts, wonderful service! My husband and I ate here recently and we will definitely be going back on our next date night. The atmosphere was very romantic and the waiter was great!... (more)
vasaprano
on Citysearch May 07, 2007I've been going to Wagstaff's for 6+ years. Sometimes alone, sometimes with business clients and sometimes with large groups. What I can say with absolute certainty is they cook their steaks, chicken, and some of... (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch Mar 05, 2007Specializing in steak and barbecue the restaurant offers a selection of slow cooked meats, wine and a cozy setting. (more)
odinjoy29
on Citysearch Jul 16, 2005Food? The steaks had NO FLAVOR! They were obviously cooked over charcoal & at a much higher temperature than necessary. The choices for "side items" were french fries, baked potato, or HASHBROWNS. Our bread choice... (more)
seazinn
on Citysearch Jul 21, 2004First time my wife and I went there was for our anniversary. The service was great but what sets Wagstaff's apart is the steak. Not only do they roll the steak to your table but the gentleman who does the cutting is the... (more)
fontfrea
on Citysearch Nov 03, 2003lacks a good or at least decent wine list. The few wines you can buy are the same main stream jug wines that mostly cheaper restaurants offer. When you can get so many good value wines, why not complete the experience?... (more)
bellwood1000
on Citysearch Mar 19, 2003Decent restaurant, but it is definitely overrated from my perspective. Most steakhouses offer filet mignon, but this establishment does not. The tables are uncomfortably close to one another and the dining room... (more)
mrslillyr
on Citysearch Feb 03, 2003WOW The prices are out of this world. Very thin cut steaks. Never go there again. Not even for free. The vegetables were ok. (more)
mdrget290
on Citysearch Feb 03, 2003If you're like me and decide WHAT you want to eat before WHERE you want to eat, Wagstaff's is the place for you . . . if you want the best steak in town. Select your cut at your table in a cozy atmosphere geared toward family... (more)
Mustangmatt
on Citysearch Jan 12, 2003Great food and service as well as an informal setting that is worthy of an excelent rating. (more)
FSundstrom
on Citysearch Dec 03, 2002A great "informal setting" restaurant which serves consistently the best beef I have tasted. A great staff and great beef makes it an experience to repeat. (more)
glenmiller
on Citysearch Dec 03, 2002I enjoy eating at this steak house above all others in the area. They treat you very well and the food is excellent. (more)
joylovesdolphins
on Citysearch Oct 06, 2002relatively inexpensive, nice quaint atmosphere overlooking the swift creek. you choose the cut of your steak when the butcher brigs it to your table. I recommend everyone go here (more)
hgmmomo
on Citysearch Aug 27, 2002What a great place! Greatest steak ever, perfectly cooked and served in a very timely fashion. Salad bar is fantastic as is the overall dining experience. I wish they would expand to accomodate more people.... (more)
fay55
on Citysearch Aug 11, 2002The steaks are brought to your table and you get to select the cut of your choice. This leads to no surprises. They are cooked to perfection and the sides are unbeatable. Their salad bar is gracious and the homemade... (more)