Mystic Pizza

860-536-3700
56 W Main St
Mystic, CT 06355
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Pizza, Restaurants
MasterCard

Customer Reviews (26 reviews)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch May 28, 2010
loved, loved mystic pizza!! Huge portions of food. One dish could feed two people. It was great to see where the movie was taped (more)

Phroggy

on Citysearch Feb 19, 2010
We went to Mystic for the day. Little did we know, not much goes on in Mystic during the winter. Regardless, we wanted to eat at Mystic Pizza so that we could say we ate there the next time we watched the... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Oct 12, 2009
Delicious and great service! The place is loaded with obvious history (Mystic Pizza the movie of course) but also with a deep menu of yummy... (more)

chuckmcdanielsfb

on Citysearch Oct 05, 2009
My family and I ate at Mystic Pizza while on a trip to the East Coast. The pizza was great and the atmosphere very quaint. I don't recall the service being poor at all -- and the pizza was excellent!... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Feb 04, 2009
Completely disappointed. It was great experience to see where the movie was filmed but that is clearly their name to fame. The pizza was hor... (more)

tazman196831

on Citysearch Mar 29, 2008
My wife and I are NOT affiliated with the restaurant at all, we live in New Hampshire and whenever we are in the area we eat there. The pizza has a wonderful crust and the cheese and toppings are fresh with a wonderful... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Mar 21, 2008
Yes, this is the Pizzeria from the movies with Julia Roberts (in her younger days) - a Pizza romance.... Nice location on the main strip an... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Feb 20, 2008
The pizza was good but not great. The place is often packed, probably due to fame from the movie. I am glad we went there - for the experi... (more)

shazamx3

on Citysearch Jan 30, 2008
I, who avoids flying (only flown twice) flew from Texas just to each this pizza. I now can't wait to go back. This was nothing like Texas pizza. The feel was like a hometown pizza parlor, not fast food pizza like Dominos... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Jan 23, 2008
This pizza place is amazing. The pizza is freshly made and wonderful, and their selection of other foods is great too. The atmosphere is nic... (more)

bonono

on Citysearch Jan 06, 2008
I live in Rhode Island and have been wanting to go to Mystic Pizza ever since I saw the movie. I finally went after taking my kids to the Mystic Aquarium, and the pizza was disappointing. The service was good, the... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Jan 02, 2008
They have a great selection on their menu, I went their with my family and it was great. Their staff was very friendly, and they were very a... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 13, 2007
Mystic Pizza, made famous by the '80s Julia Roberts movie, is a well-known pizzeria in Mystic. The offer typical pizzeria food, with a Gree... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 10, 2007
That's right, this the pizza joint that was made famous by the 1988 movie starring Julia Roberts. The pizza here is good, although there ar... (more)

pizzaboy2007

on Citysearch Sep 02, 2007
This was a very bland and almost completely flavorless pie. The crust was doughy and seemed undercooked, kind of like wet wonder bread. The only taste involved in the pizza was a generous slathering of grease. I was... (more)

miapicina

on Citysearch Aug 26, 2007
My boyfriend and I went to Mystic Pizza. It was the most horrible pizza I had ever had. The pizza I have eaten in school was better than this pizza. I had to choke down what I did have the cheese was burnt, no sauce, dough too... (more)

bpyaxley

on Citysearch Apr 12, 2007
Mystic Pizza has revamped their interior since I was a kid (and since the movie brought in a huge boost in sales), which is nicer but it has lost the a little of the charm. Although the ambiance is nice the pizza still... (more)

impossible

on Citysearch Jul 15, 2006
It's totally phony...I think most of the filming was done in Stonington Borough. Regardless, the pizza hasn't changed in years...it's thick, greasy, and not with the times. We get a chuckle out of people having... (more)

Jennifer L.

on Judys Book Apr 15, 2006
I was excited to find Mystic Pizza was a real place. I remembered the movie, but as I'm from Georgia, it pretty much faded out of my mind as anything other than the name of a movie. I was very surprised when we passed it... (more)

C. S.

on Judys Book Mar 31, 2006
I fell in love with Mystic Pizza as a kid. On family car trips to visit my grandparents we would stop at Mystic Pizza and grab a slice. I have always compared every pizza I've ever had to a Mystic pizza. I think the secret is... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state