Sally's Pizza
No photo available for this business
Business Information
Pizza, RestaurantsMasterCard
Customer Reviews (22 reviews)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 07, 2009Sally's pizza is phenomenal!! Great coal oven-cooked, thin crust, flavorful pizza. Sally's and Pepe's are New Haven institutions, and worth... (more)
EP13
on Citysearch May 25, 2009we sat quickly, but the one waiter taking orders corrected my order when I gave it to him serveral times, because evidently Sally's has their own language and own way of ordering. Everyone working there looks like... (more)
camzw54
on Citysearch Feb 28, 2009In our search for the perfect piece of pizza and after already experiencing Pepe's we wanted to try the rival Sally's. After a 1.5 hour wait in line we were escorted to our booth that was last upgraded in 1950. After... (more)
pmontero
on Citysearch Feb 27, 2009Had gone to Pepe's and wanted to give Sally's a try. Waited 2 hours outside in the rain with one 3 parties of 2 and 3 ahead of us while their preferred customers strolled in under the guise of having a reservation. Once... (more)
DBuell
on Citysearch Jan 10, 2009Waited 1 hr in line while people who called the unlisted # walked right in. Then to make matters worse on a night that was 10 degrees, they opened the doors at 5:15 while everyone froze then they kept several tables open... (more)
CSMobileUser
on Citysearch Jan 06, 2009"Speaking as a New Haven native I will tell you that this restaurant is a horrible, horrible place. There was a time 30 or 40 years ago when it was a quaint, friendly place. The service is as bad as you imagine, it's... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Nov 21, 2008After growing up in Woodbridge and going to Sally's almost every weekend as a young boy, I have traveled back from Texas many times to the N... (more)
mmec7777
on Citysearch Oct 12, 2008I was in there last night and the waitress at the counter was HORRIBLY NASTY. If she is not the owner, she should be fired. She looked like an old witch, and told me to go to Pepe's when I asked her why people were getting... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 11, 2008If you enjoy waiting forever, dreadful service in a dinghy dirty hole in the wall, this is your place. Pies are good but not worth the wait... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Jun 15, 2008My wife & I had been talking about trying this place for years since we had heard it was better than the other places on Wooster St. We h... (more)
rogersargent
on Citysearch Jan 31, 2008This is landmark in New Haven for Pizza. The sauce and the crust are very flavorful. Most of the time you will have to waite to get in here and the wait can be up to 1/2 hour long. In addition to the waite for the food. This... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Dec 22, 2007I loved the pizza when I came here. But the wait was horrible, and it was probably the slowest moving line in the world. Once we got inside,... (more)
foxyfishy14
on Citysearch Nov 14, 2007I really don't know what people see in Sally's. It has got to be the MOST OVERRATED pizza EVER! I'm originally from Mass and until I moved down to CT I had never even heard of New Haven pizza. (most people in the area think... (more)
cbmw
on Citysearch Feb 11, 2007We stopped in here on a Sunday evening. We got the last available table so expected that the food might take a little while to arrive. Well we waited... and we waited... and we waited... and FINALLY after 1 hour and 45... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Jan 10, 2007...Can be found on Worcester Street in New Haven! Sally's or Pepe's, on the same street, you can't go wrong! Cooked to perfection in a coal ... (more)
laire
on Citysearch Oct 30, 2006Until I tasted their crust and unassuming yet flavorful sauce, I was skeptical about all the hype about Sally's. It is definitely my choice over Pepe's. The wait is long. Dreadfully long. At times, mind-numbingly... (more)
kaydeej21
on Citysearch Oct 30, 2006Sally's is the best pizza, and it is accompanied by great service. I went there with a few friends on a weekday night. You do have to wait a while to get a table (because everyone loves it so much!), but when you eat the... (more)
mobrofta
on Citysearch Aug 16, 2006The crust, the sauce, the chesse. None better, not in NY, Chicago (I Live in the Chicago area), or anywhere. Pepe's is number two for me. Modern is not as good as Sally's or Pepe's. Tony's and John's in NY are good.... (more)
trmarcia
on Citysearch Jul 02, 2006I heartily recommend Sally's to all that are pizza lovers ! This place has great food in general, worth the trip down here ! (more)
bigvin
on Citysearch Feb 17, 2006I just turn 50 and left Sally's and felt like I was a kid again. I have been eating pizza on Wooster St my whole life, and the one thing that stays the same is Sally's. With Flo's (the owner) smile and her 2 sons and daughter... (more)
nicole76ct
on Citysearch Sep 28, 2004I would wait 4 hours in line for a Sally's Pizza! Not only does the atmosphere fit the traditional Italian neighborhood, but the pizza is addictive. The thin, crispy charred crust has just the right amount of oil and... (more)
biggie5182001
on Citysearch Jan 20, 2003Sally's brings me back to the neighborhood Italian restaurant of my youth on Long Island. From the many newspaper clippings, citations and celebrity photos that adorn the walls, to the always consistent and... (more)