Gaby's Pizzeria
No photo available for this business
Business Information
Pizza, RestaurantsMasterCard
Customer Reviews (37 reviews)
QVPunisher
on Citysearch Jan 19, 2010I have been going to Gaby's Pizza all of my life. I can honestly say after eating Gaby's you will not want to eat Pizza Hut, Dominos or any of those other commercial pizza spots. The pizza that is prepared there is as fresh... (more)
ali ali
on Citysearch Dec 06, 2009Gaby's Pizza is the best with numerous trophys displayed. I have flown all the way from Alaska to enjoy the pizza and today (Monday I am ordering two large pizza's (whole wheat) FROM NEW YORK TO ALASKA. They will ship... (more)
Gary Lewis
on Citysearch Aug 26, 2009I bought garlic bread today at Gabiy's and took it home. The bread was good, so I ate it. By the time I almost finished it, i realized there was muzzarela cheese inside the bread. As a vegan, I have had to buy garlic bread... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Aug 18, 2009I love it. I live on Hillside Avenue and Gaby's is a few blocks down the road. Rain or shine, it's always worth the trip. While I love the t... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch May 07, 2009I won't say I'm the greatest pizza expert, even though my name ends in a vowel (..ski), but Gaby's does have great pizza. I have had the wor... (more)
SWFL
on Citysearch Mar 06, 2009I have been living in southwest Florida for 12 years and all these places down here that say "New York style pizza" have nothing to what Gaby's have. Even though I prefer a fresh hot pizza but if Gaby's was to ever ship... (more)
jeep565
on Citysearch Jan 11, 2009I've been coming to Gaby's for years and i cannot find one complaint from there. The service is outstanding and the Food is always fresh and consistent. Other Pizzaria's cannot even come close to the taste that Gabys... (more)
woody2728
on Citysearch Jan 02, 2009Gaby's Pizzeria is the best in New York. I live a good distance from the restaurant and I still find myself passing all these other pizza stores just to get to theirs. If you haven't tried Gaby's...what are you waiting... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Dec 20, 2008The food is fine. BUT The service can be rude and snotty. All the male owners are wonderful and very friendly. However, there is a poor excu... (more)
ServicePlusTaste
on Citysearch Dec 20, 2008The food is fine. BUT The service can be rude and snotty. All the male owners are wonderful and very friendly. However, there is a poor excuse for a lady who answers the phone on the weekends and she is very nasty. She has... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Nov 27, 2008I told my husband about Gaby's pizza. That place was there when I lived around the corner from it. He considers himself a pizza maven beca... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Nov 26, 2008Gaby's serves delicious and massive slices of pizza. It's one of the few places that I'll drive out of my way to get a quick slice. Parking ... (more)
Carmen830
on Citysearch May 29, 2008To the person that compares Gaby's to Domino's Pizza - ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR MIND?! To compare Gaby's to Domino's is crazy! I live in Manhattan, but my husband used to live in Hollis. From the first time that I tasted... (more)
porfi86
on Citysearch Mar 29, 2008i noticed a couple of bad reviews about Gaby's and im thinking... "are you smoking something illegal?" Gabys IS the best pizza anywhere. YES i grew up nearby and YES im biased but guess what? when people come and visit... (more)
Niffer78
on Citysearch Feb 28, 2008This is the place my family used to get pizza at when I was little living in Jamacia, NY. Now that I live 4 hours away in upstate NY, when ever we come into the area we try to stop for the best pizza we have ever had. I have been... (more)
ynvme11423
on Citysearch Dec 29, 2007Look, I will be really honest. I grew up eating Gabys Pizza. been eating it for the last 20 years. I love everyone in the place, but however, It is not authentic Italian food. I thought it was good because I never eally had... (more)
tiki08
on Citysearch Nov 04, 2007I have been eating Gaby's pizza since I was a little girl. Thank goodness that I live in the neighborhood so I can enjoy this pizza everyday. Great service, great owners, great staff, great tasting pizza!!!!!!!!! I... (more)
ctherock
on Citysearch Oct 10, 2007Small neighborhood pizzeria hits the big times on the Rachel Ray show. After seeing the great pizza cook off on the Rachel Ray show where consumers choice Gaby?s Pizza New York faced off with the best Chicago had to... (more)
rizwoodhoodrat
on Citysearch Jul 19, 2007after reading the wonderful reviews on citysearch and noticing the rachel ray approved sign posted outside of gaby's i decided that i would stop by. i ventured out of my brooklyn neighborhood to head out to gaby's and... (more)
gooniegugu
on Citysearch Apr 25, 2007I live in Hollis and been going to Gabys for years. Even when i was in the military and came home I always took some lasagna or pizza back with me. Winning a competition out of all the pizzerias in NY and Chicago says it all.... (more)
noids
on Citysearch Oct 06, 2006User named 'washao'? you're review was far from the truth. And crowded parking lot? How much less crowded is Brooklyn on any weekend? Listen, If you find yourself in the Jamaica/Hollis area in Queens New York; more... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 11, 2005If you love like pizza you'll love Gabys. It cost a little more than other Pizzerias in the area but its still way cheaper than anything you... (more)
gasman30
on Citysearch Sep 08, 2005I've been eating Gaby's pizza since 1964 or 65...we always disagree to the opening year. Many years ago they were in a long, narrow store next to the fish store, then relocatewd to an abandoned Arthur Treacher's. The... (more)
weshao
on Citysearch Aug 31, 2005If you're a true New York pizza lover, this place will be a disappointment. If you're a tourist who only has Domino's as a local pizza parlor, this place could seem like a slice of heaven. Fortunately, I have had truly... (more)
homer98
on Citysearch Aug 20, 2005Gaby's is so good you'll eat eat there even if you aren't hungy. This place has the best pizza in NYC. The crust is perfect, the sauce is perfect, and the cheese is perfect. They also have great sausage, meatballs, baked... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Aug 14, 2005This Pizzeria is one of the greatest around. Their sauces and breads leave you wanting to come back for more. They have the best baked lasag... (more)
karimasaladeen
on Citysearch Jul 12, 2005ake your next slice A Perfect Slice, try Gaby's and you will be coming back for more. I have been going to Gaby's for over 20 years, there pizza and food is perfect. I've catered from Gabys for home and office parties and... (more)
spenc618
on Citysearch Jul 11, 2005I have been eating Gaby's pizza as long as I can remember. Being in the military and traveling extensively, Gaby's is the first place I go to when I return to NY. Food so good that I have yet to meet another person from... (more)
kawaii76
on Citysearch May 18, 2005Whenever I visit New York the first thing I crave is a slice of Gaby's pizza. The ingredients used are of a good quality and the taste is superb. Fresh tasting pizza can be hard to come by but Gaby's delivers the best!... (more)
wmnofgod
on Citysearch Apr 26, 2005I've been going to Gabys ever since I can remember & there's none like it. Not only is their Pizza the best, their Lasagna is to die for. Everything is always fresh & fixed to perfection. I live in Atlantam\ right now & I'd... (more)